October 18, 2025

I'm not a historian, but I think Trump I is worse than George III,

 


I’ll leave it to the likes of John Meacham, Ruth Ben-Ghiat, and Doris Kearns Goodwin, who are actually historians, to go deeply into a comparision between King George III and Donald Wannabe King Trump. 

However, on the morning of this No Kings protest day I do want to spitball some differences that came to mind as I was falling asleep last night.

Going back to the time of the American Revolution we had the colonists, most of whom hailed from England, deciding they’d had enough of British rule and things like taxation without representation. They decided to fight back with muskets and and artillery.

Looking at this from King George’s perspective the American were a group of ungrateful nere-do-wells who dared to challenge the rule of their rightful king. Britain was an empire, it was The British Empire! Consider how many countries they ruled and how long it took for them to gain independence. 

Click to see enlarged image.

As I see it there was no other option for King George than to put down this rebellion with the mighty British Army and Navy. He probably thought it would be easy. 

What he didn’t take into account was the tenaciousness and resourcefulness of the patriots and brilliant leadership of our Commander in Chief George Washington and his generals.

Now Trump wants to be a show-off and celebrate the coming 250th anniversary of our independence from England. If you missed this one:

Excerpt:

A senior White House official told CNN the arch was Trump’s idea.

“He came up with the design and has been part of the process every step of the way,” the official said.

Trump remains deeply attuned to his background as a real estate developer and has taken major steps since returning to office to apply his aesthetic vision to Washington, DC: paving over the White House Rose Garden and decorating it to mirror his Mar-a-Lago patio; adorning the Oval Office, Cabinet Room, and West Colonnade with gilded features; and launching a major ballroom expansion.

Last week, AFP photographer Jim Watson captured images of a pair of three-dimensional models of the proposed arch atop Trump’s desk in the Oval Office as the president met with his Finnish counterpart, President Alexander Stubb. Canadian Minister of Energy Tim Hodgson also posted a photo of Trump showcasing one of the models to a group of Canadian officials. The models were on the president’s desk again on Wednesday as he hosted an event on crime statistics.

Apparently he favors the larger version shown in the drawing above.

This photo is from NPR:

Of course the Lady Liberty statue on top is gold. 

It is something of a no-brainer to note the nauseating irony that Trump wants to celebrate our independence from a king when he wants to be one himself.

I am surprised he doesn’t try to outdo King George III and have a statue (like the one shown below) commemorating himself. It would, of course, be much bigger than Kings Statue in Weymouth, Dorset. That was installed in 1809 in honor of the Golden Jubilee of King George III who died in 1820. Trump wouldn’t want a giant monument erected after he’s dead. He want to see it.

Getting back to the comparison between the two kings, the one who actually had a crown (though he only wore it on state occasions).

Prior to independence the colonists were British. Today most people who live here are American citizens. Those to actually reside here and aren’t just visiting aspire to be citizens. Trump wants them to self-deport. If they won’t do this he plans to round them up brutalizing them in the process along with any actual citizens that end up targetted by ICE by mistake.

He also is in the process of trying to imprison all of his enemies starting with those who have pissed him off the most and working his way down to anyone who challenges his right to be king. 

Instead of conquering colonists like King George III fought a war in a failed attempt to do, Trump has started a war against more than half the country. 

This is why I think Trump is worse that King George III.

Addendum:

I think that No Kings, while a good name, doesn’t fit what Trump is doing. After all, compared to Trump, King George III was a pussycat.

The No Kings toolkit from Indivible now has “No Dictator” signs:

Perhaps by the time we have another national protest the notion of Trump being a king will be passé and we will be having No Dictator demonstrations.

Addendum: It is beyond words to describe how horrible it is that HUFFPOST is justifed in publishing Taking Photos And Videos At A Trump Protest Could Have Alarming Consequences.” 

I am posting this again today. However I am a citizen. If I am arrested or brutalized by ICE or MAGA provocateurs the headlines can emphasize that I am 81 years old.

Addendum:

One thing King George III and King Trump I have in common is that both manifest signs of being mentally ill. This is from I FEAR I AM NOT IN MY PERFECT MIND’: 7 MENTALLY-ILL MONARCHS FROM HISTORY:

George had already been on the throne for 28 years when he was struck down by his first prolonged bout of mental illness in 1788. Gibbering for hours on end and foaming at the mouth, the king’s illness was deemed serious enough for a bill to be drawn up in Parliament for his son, George IV, to become regent. Before the bill could pass, George recovered his senses and all was well with the king for the next eleven years. Then, in 1810, his mental illness came roaring back, and this time it was here to stay.

Already blind thanks to cataracts, George deteriorated rapidly. He would babble on for hours, lost the ability to walk and eventually succumbed to dementia. Towards the end of his life, he was incapable of understanding anything, such as the death of his beloved wife Charlotte in 1818 and lived as a deluded, long-haired recluse in Windsor Castle until his death from pneumonia in 1820. For the last nine years of his life, his son George ruled as regent in his stead.

Lots has been written about Trump’s mental condition. This is the most recent: ‘He’s completely nuts’: George Conway gobsmacked by Trump’s commutation of ‘fraudster’.

Thanks for reading Hal Brown's Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Leave a comment

Previous Substacks

Share Hal Brown's Substack

My comments in RawStory

RawStory: go-to site for breaking news.

My RawStory comments

I have seen a few of these but have heard them many times. They are loud. The do not sound like ordinary helicopters. Read article.

KATU (Sinclair)

KOIN

KGW

OPB

No comments:

I'm not a historian, but I think Trump I is worse than George III,

  I’ll leave it to the likes of John Meacham, Ruth Ben-Ghiat, and Doris Kearns Goodwin,  who are actually historians , to go deeply into a...