September 17, 2024

It's naive young voters who may either make the country into a dictatorship or keep our democracy, by Hal M. Brown, MSW

This got my attention on the main website page of The New York Times.


I use the word naive in my title not as a pejorative but rather as it is defined:


It is a long article. Click here to read it if you have a subscription.  I found it both informative and excruciating to read. There were parts that both dismayed me and scared the daylights out of me. This was the worst:

Give me a word or phrase to describe Kamala Harris.

Jack, 22, N.Y., white, underwriter, voted Biden in 2020

Political P.R.

Joseph, 24, S.C., white, high school teacher, voted Biden in 2020

Fake.

Angelo, 19, N.Y., Latino, college worker, didn’t vote in 2020

Confident.

Mark, 24, Calif., Black, chef, voted Biden in 2020

Politician.

Pierce, 26, N.C., white, sales, didn't vote in 2020

Phony and terrifying.

Lillian, 27, Va., white, digital advertising, voted Trump in 2020

Liar.

George, 21, Ga., white, student, didn't vote in 2020

Rehearsed.

Ayshah, 21, Iowa, South Asian, student, didn't vote in 2020

Flip-flopper.

McLane, 25, D.C., white, legal field, wrote in Romney in 2020

Insincere and shallow.

Abigail, 23, Va., white, graduate assistant, voted Biden in 2020

“Run, Spot, run.”

Jasper, 25, Calif., biracial, food service, voted Biden in 2020

An empty suit.

Ben, 20, Mich., white, student, didn't vote in 2020

All over the place.

Laura, 20, Md., white, legal intern, didn't vote in 2020

Actress.

Chris, 24, Fla., white, law student, voted Trump in 2020

Vibes candidate.


There is a cynicism expressed here. Perhaps it is because of the youth of the group. Perhaps it is because they are naive. It might be a combination of the two. I ponder whether they had some impossible expectation of how Harris could come across. Do they get their idea of how a sincere woman acts from Meryl Streep (who I happen to have seen perform live) or other actresses?

What they said about Trump reflects what I, and most observers, saw:

Let’s go to Donald Trump. Give me a word or phrase to describe Donald Trump now.

Ayshah, 21, Iowa, South Asian, student, didn't vote in 2020

Hothead.

Lillian, 27, Va., white, digital advertising, voted Trump in 2020

Undisciplined.

Laura, 20, Md., white, legal intern, didn't vote in 2020

Unstable.

Jasper, 25, Calif., biracial, food service, voted Biden in 2020

Selfishly hysterical.

Chris, 24, Fla., white, law student, voted Trump in 2020

Unviable candidate.

Abigail, 23, Va., white, graduate assistant, voted Biden in 2020

Unfocused.

McLane, 25, D.C., white, legal field, wrote in Romney in 2020

Lacking character and discipline.

Ben, 20, Mich., white, student, didn't vote in 2020

Further deteriorating.

Pierce, 26, N.C., white, sales, didn't vote in 2020

Needs a Xanax.

Mark, 24, Calif., Black, chef, voted Biden in 2020

A joke.

Angelo, 19, N.Y., Latino, college worker, didn’t vote in 2020

Pathetic.

Joseph, 24, S.C., white, high school teacher, voted Biden in 2020

Spiraling.

Jack, 22, N.Y., white, underwriter, voted Biden in 2020

Unfocused.


I was stuck that Pierce (left) called Harris "phony and terrifying" and said that Trump "needed an Xanax." I would like to have asked him what about Harris he found terrifying. Try as I might to put myself in his place I can't even imagine how anybody could describe her as invoking terror.  I'd want to know why he'd even consider voting for a candidate who he thinks needs a tranquilizer. I'd like to ask Pierce about whether he wanted a president who needed tranquilizers to be rational.

The bottom line from this article for me, which really was in the first portion, is as follows:

When we asked who they would vote for if the election were held today, five said Mr. Trump; four said Ms. Harris; and the remaining five said they didn’t know or leaned toward writing in someone else’s name. Still, the election isn’t today, and these voters haven’t committed to any candidate.

Considering the contrast between their opinions it is mind boggling to me that five of the 14 still would vote for Trump over Harris and five weren't sure. 

While maintaining democracy is the crucial reason for voting for Kamala,  leaving Trump's wanting to be a dictator out of the question, why on earth would any of them want a president who is irrational and out of control?

I posted two very different blogs today. This is the other one:






If you can't taste the Democracy killing poison in Trump's Kool-Aid there's something wrong with you.

  Sabrina Haake wrote  Governance by deception  and this prompted me to respond with the comment below. Drinking the Kool-Aid, indeed, but t...