Showing posts with label National Guard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Guard. Show all posts

September 17, 2025

A Black pastor wrote about a "makeshift Confederate army." This one has Black soldiers. By Hal M. Brown

 


I want to be sure my readers don't miss this essay by Rev. Earle J. Fisher, Ph.D., the Senior Pastor of Abyssinian Baptist Church in Memphis, Tennessee. This is the Blackest Church in Memphis and Shelby County. He’s also the founder of #UPTheVote901, a nonpartisan voter empowerment initiative committed to producing political power and increasing voter turnout in Memphis and Shelby County.

His essay begins:

This is not about crime. This is about control.

The proposed deployment of the Tennessee National Guard to Memphis is not a response to public safety. It’s a political stunt engineered by a twice-impeached, multi-indicted president exploiting Black suffering and white fear to reclaim political relevance.

It’s a charade rooted in fearmongering, cloaked in the rhetoric of “law and order” but animated by the same authoritarian impulse that called troops to Lafayette Square in Washington, D.C. and cages to the border for immigrants. And Memphis, yet again, finds itself on the night shift of American injustice.

I found the following to be a powerful and compelling message under the heading “We’ve been here before:”

In my sermon this past Sunday, I reminded my congregation that some of the most liberating work has always been done during the night shift. My mother — Claudia Mae Fisher — worked the literal night shift for decades on a bridge in Michigan. And in the spiritual and political sense, we are on the night shift right now. Just like Jesus encountering the man born blind in John 9, we are being asked who is to blame. But I contend the better question is: What is God trying to reveal through this misfortune?

As I said in that sermon, we are not called to applaud political stunts or submit to scare tactics. We are called to do the work of liberation—day or night, with or without military presence.

We are not blind. We see what’s happening.

This is the comment I posted:

The chart below is (from the official (now Dept. of War website, though still shown as Defense Department). It shows the ethnicity of National Guard members (click to enlarge).

I don’t know how many members of the Tennessee National Guard aren’t White. It is likely that the national average approximates the percentage. This hardly matters. We can assume that the figure is somewhere near a third. It is possible that for economic reasons more non-Whites join than the national average but this is just speculation. Again, this hardly matters.

Whether or not RawStory decided to use the photo they did is also open to speculation. They are a progressive publication so I wouldn’t be surprised it they decided to highlight the presence of Black soldiers in the photo. It was taken in Los Angeles. They chose it from all the other photos of Naitonal Guard in L.A. and in D.C.

Of course it is likely that some minority group soldiers approve of their assignment. I do not want to single out members of minority groups as being the only ones either appalled over what they are being ordered to do, or having less intense negative feelings about it.. I am sure many White soldiers also think they are being ordered to do something that goes against their beliefs and values.

This is from the website “The Root:”

It is true that the actual Confederate Army did have a few Black soldiers. This is from

The myth of black Confederates is arguably the most controversial subject of the Civil War. Over the past four years, the debate over whether or not blacks fought for the Confederacy has been the most discussed topic on Civil War Memory, a popular website attracting teachers and scholars from around the world, and the Atlantic Monthly and The Root have devoted several articles to it.

You can read more essays by Rev. Fisher here.

Thanks for reading Hal Brown's Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

Leave a comment

Previous Substacks

September 3, 2025

Thinking The Unthinkable, By Hal M. Brown

Tue, Aug 26 at 5:23 AM


 

I was going to write a Substack about this before I read my friend Sabrina Haake’s Substack this morning. Then I read her Substack and realized how what I was thinking fit in with what she was saying in her Haake Take titled “Blue states: Stop funding Trump's Confederacy.” It is subtitled “Previously held assumptions about federalism, including taxation, are falling.” I noticed that the illustration she used was Archibald Willard’s “Yankee Doodle” which is also known as “The Spirit of ‘76.”

I wondered why she used this painting rather than an illustration of a Civl War battle like one of these:

Still, even though she wrote about a peaceful civil war the picture is of a battlefield and you can clearly see, in addtion to the drummers and fife player a wounded soldier and a Union soldier raising his hat in victory.

This is her concluding paragraph:

A new kind of civil war is here, but Democrats did not invite it. When our backs are against the wall, facing the firing squad of a rogue president, complicit party, and corrupt high court determined to destroy us, we must act in our own self-interest. Freedom and our nation’s survival depend on it.

I agree completely with what Sabrina is saying about blue states hitting the Trump Confederacy in the wallet.

My focus is on the development we hope never comes to pass. This would be an actual armed confrontation between the New Union and the New Confederacy.

The Oregon Army National Guard consists of 41 armories in 33 communities. (Read about it in Wikipedia.)

Because we drove by one of their amories yesterday and Ann managed to take some decent photos last night I thought I’d use them as part of my Wednesday Substack.

Click above to enlarge.

There are a few scenarios which could develop where blue states would end up mobilizing their National Guards to protect themselves. Much would depend on the legal cover given if the Supreme Court came to its senses and ruled that Trump had violated the Posse Comitatus Act in sending troops to LA and DC. This could come to a head if he does this in Chicago as he has threatend to do.

If Trump defied such a ruling (Sabrina may want to weigh in on this since she’s a lawyer) and tried to take over normal law enforcement functions could the state governors order the National Guard to stop them from doing this? I seems to this non-lawyer that it is possible.

If Trump wanted his own soldiers to enforce his will, it could pit members of the Oregon National Guard against members of the Idaho National Guard (Wiki) or against members of active duty military.

I find it beyond the pale to imagine another actual replay of the Civil War with Americans shooting Americans. I could, however, see some extremely tense face-offs which resulted in a trigger happy soldier shooting someone.


Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

Leave a comment

Previous Substacks

My early nomination for the Time Person of the Year and the Nobel Peace Prize

Time Magazine’s Person of the Year, and the even more lofty Nobel Peace Prize, are the most prestigious and coveted awards that recognize...